01:51:42Joryknow to this is whoever the individual is how they feel abouts oh that's what they're saying if they feel they are a man they're a man they feel they are a
01:51:52Brian Atlasgirl still not a Munch I'm still not a Munch I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm still not a Munch wait what were you saying I believe and it's not just for people who
01:52:02Joryare INX or have a certain condition it goes for everyone however you feel you are that's what you are so if I feel like I'm a millionaire
01:52:13JoryI'm a millionaire that's not exactly howal no but that's not what I mean I mean it's up to each and every individual person to Define who they are I mean you you canot see it that way but
01:52:25Alexathat's up to you they can still be who they are what what's going on here is not the same what's going on here that's what we're trying to so what happen is when you when there is a some sort of like disruption between your mind and
01:52:35Joryyour body then that's when you you get confused I think that you are born how you're born and you can't change that so we can agree to disagree because I'm not going to change your minds and you guys
01:52:48Taylor (TayTay)aren't going to change my mind no I'm not trying to I'm not trying to change your mind I'm giving you facts that's not my opinion but those aren't necessarily facts there are you can Google it it's on there there's research you got buried treasures and you say you're a girl
01:53:00Taylor (TayTay)you're not a girl you have to literally you can get rid of it and still be trans and all that I respect the trans and all that but that's delusional if I S A Millionaire right now and you look at my bill am I a millionaire no I'm not so that's a lie you're delusional you're feeding that delusion that doesn't make
01:53:13Alexaany sense so you can believe whatever you want but the facts are there baby I mean it's like I'm coming here I'm saying I'm a dog I'm a Mastiff I'm a furry like come on I'm not a dog
01:53:22Mason GregoireI'm just not it's delusion I I think whenever I get into this conversation like I have to realize that I I I
01:53:33Mason Gregoiredisagree with what your position I don't think what you feel like is who you are male woman whatever you identify as I think that's that's extremely
01:53:44Mason Gregoiredestructive for society but when when I say that I see like I come at it as like I understand this person is a person I'm not looking at them like a piece of meat
01:53:56Mason Gregoireor an object or like as someone I'm fighting against like I I don't care about you I'm dehumanizing you I don't come at it like that like I I see it is a mental
01:54:07Mason Gregoirecondition like it is it's it's how you think you see yourself it's how you feel about yourself by definition that's it's in your head so it's it's the same thing
01:54:17Mason Gregoireas the people who are psychopaths or maybe they have other uh other psychological illnesses it's in that same category and it had been defined that way all the way up into a into a
01:54:30Mason Gregoirespecific movement so you have to treat the other person like a a human but you also have to realize Like It Is by all definitions a mental illness because I mean there's
01:54:42Mason Gregoirethere's uh a lot of negative repercussions when you buy into their delusion or their mental state it's just it's not healthy for the person and in
01:54:54Alexaindividually it's also not healthy for society as a whole and I agree with him I think that we all need to respect each other as a humans because at the end of the day we're all humans it doesn't matter we the same race we're humans but
01:55:05Alexaat the same time I will respect your choices you can make whatever choice in your life that you want to make it it has nothing to do with me but you have
01:55:15Joryto respect that I'm not going to buy into that delusion your respon well I don't know how to respond to this
01:55:26Joryconsidering there is plenty of research even within what's currently being done as well as the past that that's not it's
01:55:36Jorynot a medical disorder it's not a delusion but I don't exactly have the resources right now to like pull that up and show you guys that so I'm not going to try to change your guys'
01:55:47TTS Donation Readerminds it's just kind of disrespectful to aristal is debt donated $100 what facts determine your gender
01:55:59TTS Donation Readerchromosomes genetics these don't always agree if neither then why pretend that either is
01:56:07Jorynecessary gender itself is a construct I mean sex is different than gender so technically none of it's real if you
01:56:17Brian Atlaswant to look at it that way it is very real when I have my per every month it's real when you have PC that's not I have a chat that's going to come in here
01:56:27Brian Atlaswe have Donald Trump's brown eye okay with the 50 the there are two genders men and woman vagine and Pen
01:56:37Brian Atlasevery not my words everything else is a mental illness also everyone has a brown eye thank you for that Donald Trump that was I have a question for you poetic so
01:56:47Soniawhat if someone says that or what if someone is diagnosed schizophrenic and they say their their entire life they've been male and all of the sudden they say I'm a female but they've been
01:57:00Jorydiagnosed with schizophrenia at a young age what what would you say that is an interesting scenario because that's not exactly how schizophrenia Works schizophrenia
01:57:12Jorythere's specific types there's paranoid type as one example but it goes to specific like auditory hallucinations visual hallucinations it's
01:57:23Sonianot like a view of the self all the time like that it can be though but it's not that's really not how that work and a
01:57:31Sonialot of people who identify as trans woman man they also have mental illness like they have depression and anxiety but it's not from people not accepting
01:57:43Soniathem in fact in this day and age they're more accepted here than in any other country especially if you go to a place like my country like a thr country well and that that's why that's why like
01:57:54Mason Gregoirethis issue is important to me cuz I care about their mental well-being like there are extreme side effects that come ACR like come along with the the disorder of
01:58:06Mason Gregoirethinking that you are something that you're not it like there are higher rates of uh un living and stuff yeah yeah well I can't say exactly but yeah there's High rates of that there are
01:58:18Mason Gregoirealso extremely high rates of me mental illness outside side of uh gender dysphoria so like we can't have this
01:58:28Mason Gregoireconversation genuinely and just ignore all of that and say that this isn't a um con confounding factor to all of those other mental illnesses that are plaguing
01:58:41Alexathem I agree I think we all need to be respected because we're all humans I'm going to say that again at the same time has greatly destroyed our society what's
01:58:51Soniahappening right now and I think that go ahead you wanted to respond go ahead um I think I forgot what you had just said that I was going to respond
01:59:01Soniato that uh transgender people deserve like you know mental health yeah I like treatment the the point I'm trying to
01:59:11Mason Gregoiremake is like I want them to get better yeah I think that adding into their mental illness or trying to I guess what
01:59:22Mason Gregoirethe word I'm looking for um affirm their mental illness is going to do more harm in the long run than it does good but forcing people who identify as trans to
01:59:32Jorynot present themselves as the gender they are can also cause plenty and plenty of severe negative Mental effects it can worsen disorder like mental
01:59:42TTS Donation Readerdisorders mental illnesses it's can cause suicides as well I feel like it is a complex issue in but true truth bomb donated
01:59:53TTS Donation Reader$100 gender is not a construct sex/gender are the same thing if you think otherwise why can't a white man identify as a black man or and black
02:00:05TTS Donation Readerwoman you can't change these things trans women are men uh well a couple clarifying questions on this topic so can you change your
02:00:18Jorysex I don't think I have enough research on that specifically to say with the definitions if that's what's being done if technically you are changing the sex
02:00:29Jorybut you can have affirming surgery and have all of the parts of what you identify as they've actually made advancements in the surgery to the point where it'll be possible for people to
02:00:41Alexahave functioning uteruses in the future and actually carry that's a li that's a lie that's a lie that's a lie true the the male body doesn't have the cavity to
02:00:49Alexahold a uterus and be able to to to to make it work physically might not work possib so say I'll give you that
02:01:02Mason Gregoirewell okay so I'll just I'll give you that say they figure out a way to where some a man can get a uterus and can give birth to a child so like say they figure
02:01:13TTS Donation Readerthat out I'm just going to give Aristotle's debt donated $100 Brian I expect an answer from you at this point and I still haven't gotten
02:01:24TTS Donation Readerit also trans people have happy lives after transitioning and conversion therapy doesn't work that's actually false that's that's against most evidence yeah I would like a source for
02:01:35Brian Atlasthat well so he's expecting an answer from me specifically the the your original question was if someone is born with male chromosomes and a female
02:01:45Brian Atlasreproductive system are they a man or a woman I don't I don't know that's my answer I don't know
02:01:56Aheum there's so much of a r I think they're intercepts I think that's the answer I think they're interested I think that's the answer you know seen like those videos like those YouTube videos of people of like people who literally look like men they have the facial and everything but they have
02:02:09Brian Atlasvaginas so it's like I don't know what I can call you other than it's an extremely rare like it's an extremely rare scenario so and there's PE there's probably the majority of people who are
02:02:19Mason Gregoiretrans are not interex yeah so it so say I give you that small population say I give you the interex population the other 99.99% of people like what about them
02:02:32Mason Gregoirethey're not interex so the essentially the interex like argument you can push that off the table say I give that to you the same it's not the same thing like we we need to have a genuine
02:02:42Mason Gregoireconversation and like to do that we have to talk about what if it's just somebody who's normal uh man woman biologically we need to have that conversation cuz the
02:02:54Mason Gregoireinterex thing yeah you can you can make a medical argument for that I can give you that but going back to um uh how I was going to clarify with man giving
02:03:04Mason Gregoirebirth to baby say that happens at some point uh there the reproductive system is not the only thing that makes a man a man they are different in in their brain
02:03:16Mason Gregoirelike their brain chemistry the hormones that are being produced like bone density muscle mass the amount of fat that men carry extreme and usually the
02:03:28Mason Gregoireamount that of fat that women carry more well it's it's more than men but it's also more than men so that they can nurture their baby as they're being uh yeah as they're growing inside of you
02:03:39Mason Gregoireyeah um so I would I would argue that there are so many more determining factors that make a man a man and a woman a woman other than hey I have a uterus or hey I have a
02:03:51Jorypenis yes you agree I agree but yeah yeah so like there are other factors other than that that I would say and I would also
02:04:02TTS Donation Readeragree that there are other factors that Christ his Lord donated $100 listen for all of human history for thousands of years there has been
02:04:12TTS Donation Readerquestion as to understanding what men and women are until 20 years ago is our society becoming enlightened or is it
02:04:19Mason Gregoireunraveling evolving actually uh this is not this is not a new topic um yeah people have been trying to unravel the
02:04:29Mason Gregoirecreation order for all of history God had set man to be man and woman to be Woman made them for each other and Humanity Fallen Humanity hates that and
02:04:41Mason Gregoirethey they push away from that day after day so it's not new um it we have seen this pendulum swing in that direction over the last 20 years and I pray it
02:04:51Mason Gregoireswings back back because uh this is uh historically the downfall of society it's one of the major pillars for that couple questions here uh so I was asking
02:05:01TTS Donation Readerif you can change your sex because I think we maybe agree here at the table sex is different from gender Aristotle's debt donated $100 I don't know how I have to keep
02:05:12TTS Donation Readersaying this but androgynous insensitivity equals SL equals intersection if there are other factors that determine one's gender why not self-determination oh like you pick
02:05:24Brian Atlasyourself you pick your own gender yeah I understand he said the the sex the chromosomal sex was was male but had
02:05:35Brian Atlashold on let me see if I no female reproductive system male chromosomes so that's so you're saying that's not intersex
02:05:46Brian Atlasokay so is that a is that a thing yeah I don't know but it's not interex so what is the I don't know is that even a thing maybe this is just a thought experiment it could be is it a thought experiment or is this something that actually
02:05:58Brian Atlashappens in any case it's not clear to me if that would be the case for all people who consider consider themselves trans I don't know what is the actual medical is there a medical term or scientific term
02:06:09Brian Atlasfor what you're describing here if it's not interex is that uh there's there's other I don't know I don't know these off hand but um didn't he say it was the Androgen insensitivity thing that's the
02:06:21Brian Atlasterm they I need more descriptive like does it look so looks entirely like a woman but has male chromosomes I would again
02:06:32Brian Atlasjust ask is that actually a thing I mean I can Google it really quick andr androgenous insensitivity androgenous Androgen the hormone sensitivity do you have like an
02:06:44Brian Atlasidea syndrome AIS is when the person who is genetically male is resistant to hormones that produce a male appearance called androgens as as a result the person has some of the physical traits
02:06:56Brian Atlasof a female but the genetic makeup of a male I'm curious can they can that person um are they capable of getting pregnant cuz I know like some people are interx I know that's not what you're
02:07:07Mason Gregoiretalking about like they sometimes they can't get pregnant I don't know I don't know about there so many other medical questions that would have to be ask to
02:07:16Mason Gregoireclarify this one very very specific case like like I'm not I'm not a I'm not a medical doctor I'm not a medical doctor that
02:07:26Brian Atlasspecializes in uh like genetics the I think the argument he's trying to make is like let's use this extreme example to make the argument for the the whole Yeah well yeah so like like I said
02:07:39Mason Gregoireearlier what if I just give you that what if I say okay sure we'll let those people decide and they like okay I will let these inex people decide like they
02:07:49Mason Gregoirehave male and female character iscs like sure I can give you the that that small percentage but that still leaves the
02:07:59Brian Atlasvast majority of people that we need to have this like actual talk like we need to debate that issue is his argument also that all trans people have Androgen
02:08:11Brian Atlasinsensitivity syndrome is that the position here I don't I don't know well a couple questions on this really quick I'll try to relate it to dating um maybe
02:08:20Brian Atlaswe'll wait until she's back from the bathroom um so after actually let me read this chat I'll wait until she's back from the bathroom uh Daniel Martin ladies what if a man replied to your we'll come back to this conversation but
02:08:33Brian Atlasladies what if a man replied to your dating profile and appeared to have everything you wanted in a partner your perfect match except he was confined to a wheelchair would you give him a chance
02:08:43Brian Atlasor pass and tell you freaking rock as always thank you Daniel I agree with him so going around the table uh dating profile has appears to have everything you want in the partner perfect match
02:08:56Brian Atlasexcept confined to a wheelchair would you give them a chance or no go i' give him a chance I don't see why not I would
02:09:03Kikitoo yeah yeah I would no yes it's a perfect match all right yeah I'll wheel you
02:09:12Brian Atlaseverywhere Dazzle your wheelchair there you go dazzled I got you bedazzled I'm not that strong but I got you T not yet um it's just one question for you but
02:09:24Brian Atlasyou said that you find this sort of stemmed from our conversation about you said that you rarely see me men who are physically attractive is that correct
02:09:35Brian Atlasyeah like none yeah not really but you you'll look at a woman and be like she's beautiful yeah how fre that's much more frequent for you isn't that sexist
02:09:48Ahethough I don't maybe like maybe like girls then girls or maybe you're just a little bit resistant to you know like men like maybe you just don't want to think about them like that maybe it makes you uncomfortable it could be that
02:10:00Joryone maybe I mean I don't know why I feel that way it's just kind of how it is I mean if I feel comfortable with someone and they make me feel really happy to be around them they'll start to be much more attractive is there a like a male
02:10:13Brian Atlascelebrity you can think of that you think like no he's there's not one person you can cuz I don't know any of them there's not like one guy you can just name who you're like yeah he's attractive just physically you see him
02:10:25Brian Atlason his physically ATT what about Superman Superman I didn't get Crush Superman Spiderman huh Spider Batman anybody well actually kind of related to her thing too so we have two girls here
02:10:37Brian Atlaswho seem or I was going around on this we didn't go we didn't fully go around we'll come back to the topic at hand oh you're wait you're getting bathroom oh you're getting up I'll be quick I'm
02:10:47Brian Atlassorry okay bro all right um I Gotta Wait guys I gotta wait until she's back she could have waited but um uh Nick pull up twitch guys go to
02:10:59Brian Atlastwitch.tv/ whatever drop us a follow and a prime sub if you have one I think you have to click on new activity okay AR toal is debt donated
02:11:09TTS Donation Reader$100 duh of course I'm not saying all trans people have Androgen insensitivity not the same as interest what I am saying is that gender is a form of
02:11:19Brian Atlasself-expression no no but are you saying that Androgen in sensitivity is a form of self-expression or it it would occur to me that these
02:11:31Brian Atlaspeople have a genuine uh like a condition medical medical like there's a difference and so I'm not really
02:11:41Brian Atlassure what you're saying Aristotle um so J okay um oh here we have a message here from flat Earth denier he
02:11:52Brian Atlasdenies the Flat Earth Canadian 50 if genitals don't determine your gender why would chopping them off affirm it that's a good do you care to respond to that I
02:12:04Jorycannot speak for every single trans person but from what I do know not every single trans person do does want to have gender conf affirming surgery some
02:12:12Jorypeople are perfectly content with their physical body they just Express themsel as the gender they say they are doesn't require you to change your
02:12:25Jorygenitals you don't have to some people do some people really feel that's what they need to do so that they can feel at home in their body some people already feel at home in their body they
02:12:36Brian Atlasjust I don't even really know how to exactly I feel like it's would be it would be fruitful to go around the
02:12:50Jorytable and ask everybody's pronouns what I'm going to deny this question what that's a good second I say what I'm going to say I'm just going to get attacked it's good faith wait no
02:13:03Alexawould I attack you I'm not going to attack I'm not going to attack you I'm not going to attack we're not yeah we're supposed to respect each other like he won't attack we're just having conversation I'm going to be called delusional well I've already been called
02:13:15Taylor (TayTay)delusional I'm saying what you're saying is delusional I'm not saying you're delusional you can think however you want but it's facts if you're going and making stuff up and you can go online and Google it that is delusional if I told you right now I'm an orange man that's delusional because you're looking
02:13:28Taylor (TayTay)at me right now why I'm a black woman so I'm not saying your delusional I'm just saying what say let's leave the orange people out of this I'm just trying to be respectful I'm not calling leave the orange people out of this leave our
02:13:38Brian Atlasprobable future president out of this future president leave Trump out of this conversation um I AG did you want to respond I use any and all pronouns I
02:13:49Brian Atlashave no preference you don't have a preference because I I was going around figured hey let's get pronouns from
02:13:58Joryeverybody so wait you use any and all pronouns like does it but does it change like is it fluid yeah I guess I mean whatever anyone says at any moment if they're
02:14:10Joryreferring to me I I don't wait they get to pick what your pronouns are I mean they don't get to necessarily pick they all work they can just so I could call you he yeah you'd be fine call that on accident I see what she saying itn't but
02:14:22Brian Atlasyou'd be fine if I called you he yeah or if I called you she yeah they yeah it sure you're fine with it yeah your
02:14:32Jorymajesty you're fine with that that's can we ask why your majesty cuz I personally feel no strong connection to any gender
02:14:41Brian AtlasI feel like I just am what I am I feel like isn't it almost more offensive to be like I take them all I am all genders
02:14:53Brian Atlas[ __ ] you Pokemon I don't see how that would be offensive I could see somebody getting offended over that I mean if they do then they do I claim them all
02:15:02Brian Atlasdef I am everything I'm omnipotent but I'm not taking it away from anybody else is that all powerful it's no yeah omnipotent is all powerful your your
02:15:12Brian Atlasyour gender is Omni sure that'd be sick they SL Omni what about you your pronouns she her she her she she her she her she her Aristotle's debt
02:15:25TTS Donation Readerdonated $100 if gender affirming care gives someone a better quality of life look at the studies it is a good thing prove me wrong Brian why you coming at me I feel
02:15:37Brian Atlaslike I haven't even really had a point of yeah you got money I don't really have donating uh if gender affirming care could I think that was you who was talk about I said something about it um
02:15:50Brian Atlasgender affirming care give someone a better quality of life look at the studies it is a good thing well I mean what about people like I've heard um like d transitioners and then there's somebody who's been blowing up on
02:16:01Brian AtlasTwitter like for so to make the neop penis is what it's called or whatever they have to like remove the skin from your arm and SK they they they just like
02:16:12Brian Atlaspeel the skin from from your arm here I guess for what to make a to give a woman who's transitioning into a man a p
02:16:22Brian Atlasand like it gets infections or something look I don't know is it I actually wait hold on I have to now I have to wait till she's back to ask these [ __ ] okay can I say something about that real
02:16:34Ahequick though nobody leave once she gets back please so I can go around asking the question what's your thing I feel like as you know Daniel the whole gender affirming care I think we should also you know give a lot of effort to find
02:16:46Aheout why they feel the way that they feel because especially right now this whole you know debate on gender and stuff this is like a new thing okay I did not grow
02:16:56Aheup with this and I'm what just literally 21 so this you know we should also figure out why this is a thing because I don't think that people are really dealing with I don't know what gender I
02:17:08Alexaam I don't no it seems like a deeper yeah it's definitely something else yeah I think a part of the is um
02:17:17Alexayour family structure how how you are growing up uh the father um picture you know like I think a lot of people who grow up with their father and mother and
02:17:28Alexaor or or the father was around whatever has a better upcoming life than an absent father I I think you're hitting
02:17:37Mason Gregoireon something really important right here like I I think the lack of male figures in our culture the lack of strong male
02:17:46Mason Gregoireleadership is I think what breeds all of this nons sense it like if you don't have men who are willing to stand up and say this is what is right this is what
02:17:56Mason Gregoireis wrong the lead the leaders yes if you don't have men showing you what a man is then I can see how all of these things can be questioned if you have men
02:18:07Mason Gregoirewalking around being able pushed over like their children and they have no stances on anything and nothing is important to them and they'll just say whatever they can say to get laid like obviously people are going to have a
02:18:20Mason Gregoiredifficult time understanding the difference between a man and a woman but when you have a society that has a strong emphasis on what a man is what are you supposed to do what his duty is
02:18:29Mason Gregoireto protect to provide uh to uh lead when you don't have that I can see how all of this stuff comes out like everything crumbles yeah yeah like if you grow if you grow up in a household with no
02:18:42AlexaFather Figure what does it mean to be a man because as as a girl growing up like it wasn't so important uh know that my dad was protecting me and he was there for me
02:18:51Alexaso imagine growing up and don't have that that uh male figure as a father that you know it will protect you I'm not saying your mother won't absolutely there's moms like my mom that will
02:19:04Alexaprotect me with her life mothers are extremely important extremely important and but the father is has that job of protecting you and making sure you're safe you know and and and and guiding
02:19:14Mason Gregoireyou and being the leader another interesting statistic that uh has borne out is that families I I don't want to butcher this I I might mess up when I
02:19:25Mason Gregoiresay it but families that have a two parent household uh their children uh their statistical likelihood of going to prison uh graduating high
02:19:36Mason Gregoireschool all of like a bunch of these negative uh not graduating in high school getting uh having children out of wedlock those negative predictors they
02:19:46Mason Gregoirehave the same statistical likelihood of avoiding those if they have a single father household and it doesn't hold the same for a single mother household it shows I'm I'm not bashing single mothers
02:19:59Mason GregoireI think women who are raising CH children by themselves that that is an extremely hard hard place to be in and I empathize uh with your position I think
02:20:10Mason Gregoireit's a a crime uh against you because I mean we've had a society that has promoted that for um a very long time especially in minority neighbor hoods
02:20:21Mason Gregoireminority communities um but yeah it shows the importance of fatherhood and I think fathers are extremely important extremely important extremely couple questions here and then we'll get back
02:20:33Brian Atlasto the what percentage of men you find attractive question so okay we were talking about the you know the gender stuff um so I think a one good clarifying question we should asked the
02:20:43Brian Atlaswhole panel the whole table here is and I and I'll actually relate it back to dating here in a bit what is a
02:20:54Soniawoman a woman is whoever defines thems as a woman an adult human female a person who has female genitals and chromosomes yeah I'd probably say
02:21:07Mayasomeone who I identifies as a woman someone who has female same as her jals and crimon same you're only a woman
02:21:16Joryif you can have your period and have kids there plan of biological women who can't do either of that either we're not we're just we're just do you mean like the essence of okay all right I know
02:21:29Brian Atlasthere's some women who cannot bear a child so I'm not talking about those type of women but you know what I mean wait so so just for for you two since I think you guys said that a woman is somebody who identifies as a woman is
02:21:40Brian Atlasthat I don't want to misstate your positions is that correct so can you I'm perhaps you can provide a more precise definition can you define what a woman is without using the word
02:21:56TTS Donation Readerwoman someone who defines thems as such as well you haven't really improved a whole lot on the requested definition kill of Serial donated
02:22:07TTS Donation Reader$100 so long as the message isn't pushing kids to mutilate themselves by praying on their uncertainties adults who want to be delusional live in the
02:22:17Alexacountry to do so and they can must protect the kids AG very much agree love that kill cereal I think if you're an adult and you want to do whatever you want to that's fine but with kids like
02:22:28Alexawhen I was five years old I used to say I want to be an astronaut I want to be a vet is it's the same thing if you tell if you let a kid make that decisions as such a young age and as an adult do whatever you want but let's protect the
02:22:41Brian Atlaskids until they can come to an age they can make their own decisions do you have any thoughts on that when it comes to children like cuz I think it sounded like you were in favor of gender affirming care um what any thoughts on
02:22:54Joryyou know someone who's 11 12 13 or do you think I feel like they should still be able to express themselves how they choose that doesn't necessarily mean surgery of course children should not be
02:23:06Jorygoing going under severe serious surgeries necessarily I mean there's plenty of checks that are done so to keep people from doing this if and it prevents tons of trans people who are
02:23:19Brian Atlastrans from even this care because they're not deemed as qualifying for the surgeries but what about like uh the the hormone medicine what's that called hormone
02:23:30Joryblockers pu puberty blockers thank you yeah puberty block puberty blockers you can take them as a kid and then when you go off them it I from what I know cuz I don't know a lot about puberty and
02:23:40Brian Atlashormone blockers it doesn't keep you from developing those traits later in life if you decide to go off them wait so you're saying for examp let's say someone from the age when does does puberty typically start 10 11 12 around
02:23:53Brian Atlasthere let's just say they started I don't know the let's say the age is 12 they from 12 to 20 they use these puberty blockers I don't know if that's the typical age they continue using it
02:24:04Brian Atlasuntil but are you saying that once they get off it at 20 that it would it would like they would just go ahead and have their puberty at 20 is that I'm not
02:24:15TTS Donation Readerfamiliar with the I'm not fully familiar with hormone blockers either so I conely say Christ his Lord donated $100 the reason we are dealing with
02:24:26TTS Donation Readergender confusion is moral Decay without God Romans 1 says just as they did not see fit to acknowledge God God gave them up to a depraved
02:24:37Brian Atlasmind yep true true Christ is Lord okay thank thank you for the TTS appreciate it um wait so okay uh but so you don't
02:24:48Joryobject to the use of pu puberty blockers in children is that no I don't object I feel like there's a lot of checks and balances in place that even prevent people who really want to go on them
02:24:58Joryfrom even being able to go on them so it's it's not a foolproof system but it's really really hard for someone to just willy-nilly go on something like that is it yeah I don't know your
02:25:09Sophiathoughts on that like cool for the kids to go on puber puberty blockers um I don't know about other people's kids but for my own kids I
02:25:20Sophiathink it just would I honestly don't really know I'm not okay anywhere close to that I also I think my view of gender
02:25:28Sophiais is kind of like I know what I am and other people you know the way I said that women means that like how people identify themselves is
02:25:40Sophiathat I think that that is true because if someone thinks that they are woman and maybe biologically they weren't born a woman I won't interfere with that and
02:25:50SophiaI I think it's a lot to say that is a mental disorder because sexuality was also considered a mental disorder for a very long
02:25:59Brian Atlastime and sometimes it's still considered a mental disorder well sexuality is a mental sexuality like being gay yeah so let's let's stick though to the
02:26:11Brian Atlasconversation in hand here so um strictly when it comes to the puberty blockers thing when it comes to kids taking them in favor against
02:26:20SophiaI think I might be more against it for kids I I know that I'm kind of like I don't really know because I don't know if it's like if you wait too long if you can't take them then and if you know
02:26:33Jorylike I'm not really sure how it works exactly and I think it would just really depend on you know the case one thing I do know about puberty blockers is they don't work if you take them later they only work if you take
02:26:45Jorythem early enough to prevent the hormones from making the permanent changes so you can always go off of them and then get those changes but you can't undo them necessarily well I I have seen
02:26:56Brian Atlassome research and I don't think it's true I don't think it's true that like you you've say you were born a male but
02:27:04TTS Donation Readeryou want to Aristotle's debt donated $100 let boys choose whether their penises get sliced and diced until you oppose MGM I can't take your transphobic
02:27:23Brian Atlasmale wait until you oppose male talking that's it's interesting it's actually interesting you raise that
02:27:31Brian Atlasbecause I actually do object to circumcision so I don't know I do oppose uh
02:27:40Brian Atlascircumcision um I don't what's been transphobic about any of this conversation though um we kind of an opinion anymore without everything
02:27:50Brian Atlasit's a phobic ISM nobody hates nobody um wait wait okay we were on the puber oh so I do think it's the case like you
02:28:01Brian Atlascan't once you've made the change with the puberty blockers or whatever there's no reversal like you've hit 20 you were on that for five six seven8 years
02:28:12Joryhowever long you're not just going to switch back there might a pause button you could also take hormon later in life you could but do you think it would be the
02:28:23Brian Atlasit's going to end up being the same as if you just proceeded through puberty as you as normal I'm sure it wouldn't be the same well what are your thoughts on the de like people who detransition people are allowed to
02:28:34Brian Atlasdetransition it doesn't take away from people who are trans okay people can change their identity it sounded like you're fine with the puberty blockers if I have that is that
02:28:45Jorycorrect for children I would believe so but I don't have that much knowledge on specifically puberty blockers sure well question for the panel on this so say you're let's say you have kids in the
02:28:58Brian Atlasfuture I know you don't want to have kids but let's just for the sake of this conversation hypothetical here say you have an 11-year-old uh daughter son doesn't
02:29:06Brian Atlasreally matter they come to you at 11: and they want to get a tattoo would you allow them to get a
02:29:15Jorytattoo how old are they again B 11 oh no get a tattoo but the same thing with u gender or going on to a type of medication or surgery if it's the one in
02:29:28Joryfirst time they brought it up I probably wouldn't let them just go on something like that either it's it's got to be something they felt and wanted for a really really long time and it's really serious and take them through the checks
02:29:39Joryand balances to make sure it is what they feel and they it's what they really want and they understand the long-term consequences and effects to the best of their knowledge and after a couple of years
02:29:51Sophiaokay uh we'll go around the table on this absolutely not no I don't know I
02:30:00Brian Atlasthink not yeah I don't really care no no no yeah definitely not okay um last I don't want to linger on this for too
02:30:10Brian Atlaslong because we've been here for a while two two two two things okay um here let me bring it to dating so this is not have been about relationships in a while I know well hey
02:30:22Brian Atlasthis guy's uh it wasn't me who brought this up this other guy he's really he's hijacking he's he's hijacking uh okay
02:30:33Brian Atlasso would it in terms of dat okay in terms of dating would you object to a man not wanting to date a trans woman I feel like there's a lot to that
02:30:45JoryI feel like for the safety of the trans person then probably because if someone was with that trans person and they were together and they found that they were trans and they're like I don't like this and then they take the violence out on that person I feel like it in that case
02:30:58Joryit's probably good for the person to ahead of time not inter like you know for that to not become a situation to begin with so if the person is like violent towards trans
02:31:10Jorypeople let's say they're not they're not they just don't want to date somebody who's trans I feel like do you object to that people have their
02:31:20Jorypreferences I feel like that says something about that person but there's still allowed to have what does it say Nick keep it on starting I mean it kind
02:31:32Joryof says that they probably don't view that person as an actual woman if they're not willing to date them and their preference is women okay um so then well I actually
02:31:44Brian Atlaslet me get everybody's answer on this but um so you would object to a man not wanting to date a trans
02:31:54Jorywoman well I not necessarily object I'm just saying that if that's the view they have then it probably says they don't see that person as a woman which means
02:32:03Brian Atlaswhat that that's just how they person uh uh bro
02:32:15Brian Atlaswhat question for the table is it okay to cut up a baby Pro for p uh for religious reasons if so is it also okay to cut up a bro what you asking some
02:32:27Brian Atlascrazy goofy questions bro spending a lot of money on these question even for look even for religious reasons I'm against circumcision because I believe in
02:32:37Brian Atlasadvocating for men and boys before any of that so um yes I'm against it um we're not going to linger too long on that though so wait so okay it says what
02:32:49Brian Atlasabout the person I've already said what it say person it interrupted you I I just wanted you to just be able to restate your position well it says that that
02:33:00Joryperson does not see that other person as a woman which means what about them that means exactly that do you object to
02:33:10Jorythat I say that it's probably not the greatest thing that they don't see that person as a woman but what if they don't see them as a female do you object to
02:33:22Brian Atlasthat well females technically they're sex yeah so no I don't object to that okay um
02:33:33Brian Atlasso you you were also saying how if somebody was dating somebody and then they found out like down the road that they were trans so in the scenario that
02:33:44Brian Atlasyou provided this is somebody who I assume is very much passing as a transwoman do you think this is sort of a different topic do you think that
02:33:56Brian Atlasthere is a duty for Trans people to disclose to romantic partners that they're trans I don't think there's necessarily a duty because for that to be a responsibility of them can put them
02:34:08Brian Atlasin danger I mean they can choose to disclose that if they feel they are safe well let's talk about the safety thing wouldn't it put them in more danger to
02:34:17Brian AtlasOmit and not disclose their sexual status with a partner who might object to being in some way misled I'm so sorry I feel like I cannot speak for Trans
02:34:29Jorypeople I'm not trans I don't experience their experiences so I'm donated $100 good for you Brian but it was a question for the
02:34:47Brian Atlasum bro you're you're der ing the conversation a little bit but so if you wait Aristotle I'll ask it to the table but I'm going to get through a couple things here so you're going to
02:34:58Brian Atlashave to wait a sec go ahead I think I finished my answer I have wait wait hold on before you come in let me just get around the table on this
02:35:10Brian Atlasso um okay you when it comes to the safety thing you don't object or you do
02:35:22Brian Atlasobject no no sorry you do you oh my God sorry guys I'm tongue twisted here you don't object to a trans person not disclosing their trans status to
02:35:33Brian Atlaspotential romantic partners for safety reasons yeah they don't have to a lot of the times they do you think people should
02:35:42Jorydisclose their STD status to a partner yeah okay that is something that can be be transferred to the other person you can't transfer anything from
02:35:54Brian Atlasbeing transfer person but that's okay hold on be good faith though that's not what I'm arguing but I there you would agree that there are certain things that you ought to disclose to a romantic
02:36:04Brian Atlaspartner yes for example do you think do you think you should disclose if you're in another relationship with somebody well that's not something you can transmit to somebody but like that is
02:36:15Brian Atlassomething that EIC speaking of their lives like their tangible lives well let's say for example you're dating with the intention of marriage and having children and this person
02:36:26Joryis they're male they cannot have children they can disclose they can't have children they can do that at some point along the relationship people who are infertile don't always disclose from the beginning of a date that they are
02:36:38Brian Atlasinfertile sometimes they may sometimes may not it let's say I'm on a first date with somebody and I make it pretty clear to them that you know I'm looking for something longterm I'm looking for something serious I'm looking for
02:36:49Jorymarriage and I'm looking for kids down the road and if the other person doesn't want kids or can't have kids then it's just a relationship that wouldn't work they don't have to necessarily let you know they're trans but they can let you
02:37:00Brian Atlasknow they don't want and don't want to have kids okay fair enough so but you seem to I mean to me it
02:37:08Brian Atlasseems pretty questionable to not disclose uh your gender sex status or whatever up
02:37:20Joryfront maybe it is maybe it isn't I personally am not the one to answer these questions I am trans I don't have that experience I can't speak for their Community okay but you can give your own
02:37:32Mason Gregoireopinion in my opinion I still don't think they have to disclose that they're trans so you don't have to give the caveat that you're not a part of their Community like like I'm not going to ask
02:37:44Mason Gregoireeveryone to give a caveat for the reason they're saying what they're saying like I'm allow you to have an opinion and I don't need you to like give your credentials for why you have this opinion like I want to listen to you
02:37:57Brian Atlasbecause you're you like I want I listen to you because you're a human being you don't have to give your credentials every time you say something here we're going to move on we're going to go around the table do you object would you
02:38:08Brian Atlasobject to a man not wanting to date a trans woman and this could you could flip the the genders here a a a woman not wanting to date a trans men yeah I'd want to know if they were
02:38:21Brian Atlastrans okay I wouldn't object I would not object I'm sorry what was a question again would you would you object to a man or a woman not wanting
02:38:32Brian Atlasto date somebody who's trans trans man trans woman no it's their preference let them do what they want yeah I wouldn't object okay it
02:38:42Brian Atlassounded like you objected a little bit to that one I feel like it's a complex situation it's not really it's just about
02:38:53Brian Atlaspreference okay and that needs to be respect do you think men ought to be obliged to date somebody who's trans well if you don't like the person you shouldn't have to date them let's
02:39:05TTS Donation Readersay you do like the person let's say they're well if you do like the person kill of cial donated $100 what if you're a trans Ted Bundy he will disclose his transition but not the
02:39:16TTS Donation Readerfact that he wants you next L is with holding information considered Ling what does that Bible have to say uh wait what does the Bible have to
02:39:27Mason Gregoiresay about trans Ted Bundy that is a good question avoid Ted Bundy at all in any scenario um yeah yeah murder and uh yeah the depraved
02:39:39Brian Atlasmind I don't have thank you thank you kill of Serial um I'm sorry you were saying I I think you were saying like well if you like the person then what well if
02:39:52Joryyou like the person why wouldn't you want to date them like if you like them okay they're your preference why wouldn't you want to date them because they're not the gender well say or
02:40:04Mason Gregoirethey're not the sex that you're attracted to I I can put myself in this scenario I would personally be disgusted if I was if let's say just like crazy
02:40:15Mason Gregoirescenario I married a trans woman I had no idea she she was train she sold herself really really well the whole time and like hit hit it super well and
02:40:26Mason Gregoireuh we got married and I eventually figured it out like I would be absolutely disgusted like that needs to be something that's said it it's like as disgusting to me as having an STD
02:40:38Mason Gregoireprobably even more so like that needs to be disclosed and I would say the vast majority of guys out there and women out there would probably feel the same they would feel violated they would feel
02:40:49Mason Gregoiredisgusted like it's a very serious personal issue I can't trust you is exactly like it I understand like yeah
02:41:00Mason Gregoirethis person wants to find somebody else but like it's extremely deceptive and hurtful and you're not you're coming from the point of view it would hurt the person who is trans but it would you
02:41:13Mason Gregoirealso have to consider that the other person is also human and they want to find somebody for themselves and it's extremely selfish to hold that information from that other person and if I can just say something real quick I
02:41:25Ahemean why you know as a trans trans person you know if you're proud of being trans if you you know can affirm to yourself that you're trans why wouldn't you want to disclose that with somebody you know what I mean and also in
02:41:37Aherelation to like okay let's say um you had herpes right something like that and oh sorry okay so let's say you had like herpes or something right why would you not tell that to somebody who you're
02:41:47Ahedating and you know intend having a relationship with because that can also first you have the herpes you can give it to them and then that can go down to your children it's a whole you know it has to be disclosed because you know if
02:42:00Ahethat person really likes you really truly and wants to get to know you that might be something that won't bother them you know what I mean but I mean why would you even want as a trans person I can't understand why you wouldn't why
02:42:11Ahewould you want to be with somebody who is transphobic in the first place or does not want to date a trans person because it's not that's it's not to not want to date somebody well not like that
02:42:22Brian Atlasnot like that but that's how yeah that's the language they would use probably yeah but is that is that kind of your argument that it would be transphobic to not want to date somebody who's
02:42:35Jorytrans I don't know like I really don't know that's a fair answer you don't have to
02:42:42Brian Atlasknow okay um well okay so let me ask a couple more clarifying questions so
02:42:50Brian Atlaslet's say that this trans woman is has a penis would that be reason enough for me to not want to date them I don't want to
02:43:01Brian Atlasdate whe whether they're however they identify they're woman transwoman I don't want to date someone who has a penis is that reason
02:43:12Joryenough maybe but maybe you should put on your profile that's your preference I need to wait I need to put on my profile that I don't want want to date someone who has a penis yeah you could put in your own reference that you don't want
02:43:25Joryto date trans people and that'll make the other person's decision for them because then they won't pursue you so wait I need to change my behavior like can't I just say I'm straight wouldn't that be
02:43:38Jorysufficient I mean if you're straight in excludes trans people then it's not just straight for everyone who's a
02:43:47Jorywoman but it what very muches on people actually seeing the trans person as what they identify as if you don't see them as a woman then like yeah technically you're straight but that's not straight
02:43:58Joryby everyone's definition so it's kind of will leave room for ambiguity ambiguity because other people will what is your let me have a little yeah what what is your definition of
02:44:12TTS Donation Readerstraight people of opposite gender which is not sex Aristotle is donated $100 damn that guy is a homophobe short
02:44:24TTS Donation Readertrans people should disclose that they're trans but do you really think gay sex is worse than an STD dang dude no one said
02:44:34Alexathat did yeah do you think that gay let's not no no no we're not let's not go there I don't want to derail the conversation yeah let's not derail the conversation but um go
02:44:48Joryahead I would say it's people of opposite gender who are attracted to each other and um okay Cy man and a trans woman are opposite gender so you could be
02:45:00Joryattracted to each other and still be straight it is reasonable for someone else to assume just because you say you're straight doesn't exclude trans people but you're saying even a trans
02:45:09Brian Atlasperson who has a penis yeah so what if okay so my understanding of what straight is
02:45:18Brian Atlasstraight is short form slaying for heterosexual would you agree yeah okay so whether you're heterosexual or
02:45:30Brian Atlashomosexual that seems to point towards sex not gender so when we say homosexual we mean same seex
02:45:39Brian Atlasrelationship so how can it possibly be heterosexual for two males to in to be Roman ically or
02:45:49Jorysexually involved well that hinges on your definition of it being specifically the definition though but it's not pull up but okay homosexual two males heterosexual male
02:46:04Joryfemale my definition of it would be by
02:46:11Mason Gregoiregender see this actually a tough one that's a tough one for me this actually kind of goes into the point that I I was going to make and I mean this as well as possible but one
02:46:22Mason Gregoireof the uh Hallmarks for narcissism is that you you have internal issues you have internal struggles that you are
02:46:31Mason Gregoireworking through and you expect everybody around you to to change to cater to those personal issues and that can
02:46:40Mason Gregoirehappen in it doesn't necessarily mean in the realm of um of uh sex and gender it can also be in the realm of dating like if I my girlfriend um if I bring